Wednesday, February 24, 2016

A Short Analysis of Donald Trump's Economic Proposals

As Donald Trump edges towards winning the Republican Party nomination for President of the United States, I will break down Trump's economic proposals that he has for the United States. Three of the main proposals he has proposed will actually be very detrimental for the country. These three include deporting millions of Americans, large tariffs on goods with China, Japan and Mexico and an extremely unfriendly foreign policy towards the Middle East.

By deporting millions of undocumented Americans from Latin American countries such as Mexico, he might cause a large shortfall in minimum wage and other low wage positions in agriculture, in food preparation and in perhaps janitorial roles. There aren't enough people in the country that will comfortably fill those positions as those have been mostly filled by new immigrants, some of them illegal. While some of the domestic unemployed might be able to fill in some of these positions, they won't be able to cover all of these positions as some of the more vulnerable local populations might not want to even take these jobs, without a modest wage increase. While it might decrease unemployment among the working population, this might create a large void in the service economy and that might result in prices going up.

The second and most damaging of his economic proposals would be to slap large tariffs on goods with countries that provide some of the products that are consumed in this country such as China, Japan, Mexico, South Korea and elsewhere. His rhetoric contends that this will help to revitalize America's flagging domestic manufacturing industry, but this does not seem like it will be the case. The best case scenario will cause some of these offshore jobs to move to even lower income countries such as Indonesia, Vietnam and India and cause prices for goods and services to raise accordingly to the rate of tariffs. You would have to slap prohibitive tariffs to move the low-wage manufacturing jobs back to the country. Prices on everyday goods such as t-shirts might even double as a result of this import tariff. This will surely increase the costs of living in the United States and it will hit the working people even harder. The cheaper goods that the country has been receiving (some of the cheapest in the world) has been caused by low tariffs to low to middle income countries such as China, Mexico and cheap higher-quality goods from countries such as South Korea. This has been a boon for the working people to consume more cheaper products and has helped to move some of those same people into more value-added service positions that contribute to the less manufacturing intensive some of the economy. This has also been environmentally feasible for the country as heavy manufacturing plants has caused massive population problems for a country such as China. Let's also not talk about a massive trade war with China or a tariff war with the European Union...

The third and last of his proposals has been quite damaging for America's image and relations with countries in the Middle East as to outlaw all Muslims coming into the country might cause more hostility towards the United States in those Middle Eastern states. This might be an ideal solution for Trump but this might cause a breakdown in commerce between the United States and the Middle East. While relations with certain states in the Middle East such as Iran and Syria might not improve under President Trump, relations with allies such as Turkey, Saudi Arabia and Egypt might be strained. While the economies of this region do not figure much to America's export economy, it might cause a strain in developing good relations with a region that is so vital to providing the oil and gas to the world's second largest economy (the United States). By promoting and causing more Muslim hostility to the United States, the country might have to spend more on its wasteful military spending that does not provide much benefit to the domestic consumption economy of the United States and further drag the federal government into the brink of bankruptcy.

From these three proposals we can see briefly that a Trump Presidency will be horrible for the country's economic well-being, along with foreign policy problems with Muslim countries due to his well documented Islamophobic comments in order to win more fear on his behalf. While relations with countries such as Russia might improve under his presidency, he might cause rough relations with manufacturing countries such as China and South Korea. This would not put the United States in the right footing as to compete with these countries on a global level with heavy tariffs damaging domestic American firms' capabilities to compete on the international level. By deporting millions of undocumented immigrants, he might also put those that might be able to work in manufacturing jobs back to their home countries. Like Trump has used his "huge" quote on many things such as his proposals and his campaign, a President Trump would cause severe economic problems in the United States. This short blog post is just a brief summary of the problems that a President Trump would have and we will find out and see if the country is smart enough to elect a President other than Donald Trump.

No comments:

Post a Comment